Incident vs Problem: What’s the Difference?

For the rest of the world, these are just two synonyms. But in ITIL, the main IT service management framework, the distinction is crucial. Let’s find out.

Illustration of an iceberg labeled "Incident" above water and "Problem" below water, with icons representing issues and a diver investigating.

What is an incident?

ITIL, a service management framework, describes an “incident” as an unexpected disruption in service. Incident management is the process of finding and fixing these issues to restore services to normal quickly. The main goal of incident management is to keep business disruptions to a minimum and ensure IT services are restored as soon as possible.

What is a problem?

However, incidents sometimes serve as indicators of a deeper underlying issue–a problem.

ITIL’s definition for a problem is “a cause or potential cause of one or more incidents.” To determine and resolve this underlying issue, you need a separate process, i.e. problem management.

In Alloy Navigator, the comprehensive ITSM platform by Alloy Software, problem management is tightly integrated with incident management, change management, and knowledge management for effective and quick resolution.

  • Automatically close associated incidents once the root problem is resolved.
  • Let automation handle the closure of all resolved problems, removing them from your radar after a set period with no recurring incidents.
  • Capture workarounds and permanent solutions and effortlessly publish them to the integrated knowledge base with a single click.
  • With an interactive relationships map, you can gain a complete picture of all related CIs, incidents, and change requests. Check out the screenshot below.

Connect with our sales team if you want to learn more about our solutions!

Incident vs problem: the difference

Incidents are defined as unexpected disruptions to a service, such as a service outage, that interrupt normal operations.

  • The primary goal of incident management is to quickly identify and resolve these incidents, restoring normal service operations as soon as possible to minimize business disruptions and negative impacts.
  • This process involves several steps, including identifying, logging, categorizing, prioritizing, investigating, resolving, and closing incidents. Communication with users about the status and resolution of the incident is also a key part of this process.
  • Incident management is reactive, addressing immediate issues as they occur and focusing on a swift response to restore service.

In contrast, problems refer to the underlying causes of one or more incidents. These are often identified when multiple incidents, such as recurring outages, share a common root cause.

  • The goal of problem management is to identify and eliminate these root causes to prevent future incidents. When a permanent solution isn’t available, a temporary workaround is recommended.
  • The problem management process includes steps such as problem identification, logging, categorization and prioritization, investigation and diagnosis, resolution, workaround identification and documentation, and closure.
  • Unlike incident management, problem management is proactive, focusing on resolving the underlying issues that lead to incidents and aiming to prevent future unplanned disruptions.

Problem management lifecycle and incident management lifecycle

You can look at the lifecycles of incidents and problems to make differentiating between them easier.

An incident can be resolved and closed if at least a workaround has been found. The workaround will be documented in the manner accepted within the company, for example, entered into the Known Error Database (KEDB). The problem management team will then work on this incident to address the underlying problem that caused it.

While problem resolution might involve finding a workaround, problem managers can also raise change requests when they realize the problem requires significant changes to the system or processes.

Incident vs. problem management graphic.

Why is it important to manage incidents and problems separately?

As IT processes grow and become more strategic, businesses need to look back and learn from past mistakes.

Managing incidents and problems separately allows services to be restored quickly while also working on long-term solutions to prevent future issues. This approach ensures immediate problems are resolved and underlying causes are addressed.

Finally, fixing one problem that causes many incidents saves money spent on fixing those incidents.

Incident management and problem management: the connection

Many experts emphasize the need for continuous communication between the incident and problem management processes. Effective communication involves the following efforts:

  • shared meetings,
  • regular updates on problem investigations for incident response agents,
  • and collecting incident data to improve problem investigations.

One reason for the lack of connection between these teams is the distinct nature of their jobs. Incident teams act like firefighters, quickly fixing issues to restore services. In their rush, they might skip the best practices that problem management teams rely on, like thorough investigations and data collection.

This difference can cause tension. Problem management teams might believe that incident teams neglect essential procedures, while incident teams might see problem teams as overly meticulous. It’s like the rivalry between sales and marketing, where each thinks they do the harder work. In reality, both teams complement each other.

Despite this tension, it’s even more important to make sure these teams work together. This connection ensures that both immediate and long-term issues are addressed effectively.

Incident management, problem management, and other ITSM processes

Incident management and problem management processes are tightly connected to other ITSM processes.

Incidents, problems, and assets

IT asset management is essential for supporting incident and problem management. The ITAM team helps incident and problem teams by providing them with proper data about hardware and software assets, such as what laptops were affected by the recent incident or what switch might be causing a problem.

Problem management and change management

When problem management pinpoints the root cause of repeated incidents, it frequently leads to modifications in the IT system or processes. This is where change management plays a role by implementing the needed adjustments. By establishing a well-structured change management process, organizations can guarantee that changes are thoroughly evaluated, planned, and executed, reducing the chances of new issues or disruptions arising.

Start your trial with Alloy Software today

Key takeaways

  • Incidents are unexpected disruptions that require quick fixes. Problems are the root causes of multiple incidents that require thorough analysis and long-term solutions.
  • Maintain regular joint meetings and use common communication platforms to ensure problem management and incident management teams stay coordinated and informed.
  • Set clear rules for when an incident should become a problem and keep documentation consistent. Use shared knowledge bases and tools to ensure smooth integration between incident and problem management.

Frequently asked questions

What do end users create? Incident or problem?

End users typically create incidents. When they encounter an unexpected disruption or issue with a service, they report it as an incident to the IT support team. The IT team then manages and resolves the incident. If multiple incidents have a common root cause, the IT team will identify it as a problem and initiate the problem management process to address and resolve the underlying issue.

What are the best practices for handling incidents and problems?

Integrated processes

Ensure that incident and problem management processes are closely integrated with clear guidelines on how incidents transition into problems. For example:

  • Use a shared format and terminology for documentation
  • Maintain a centralized knowledge base that includes information on incidents, problems, workarounds, and permanent solutions.
  • Use ITSM tools that allow for easy tracking, linking, and transitioning of incidents to problems.
  • Create feedback mechanisms where the problem management team can provide insights to the incident management team about recurring issues and potential root causes. Conversely, incident teams should inform problem teams about any new patterns or anomalies they encounter.

Regular joint meetings

Schedule regular meetings between incident and problem management teams to discuss ongoing issues, share insights, and align strategies. Promote cross-training for the two teams to improve understanding and collaboration.

Unified communication channels

Utilize common communication platforms and tools for both teams to ensure smooth information flow. In most ITSM software solutions, including Alloy Navigator, problem and incident management are integrated.

Continuous training and development

Provide ongoing training for both teams on best practices, tools, and techniques relevant to incident and problem management. Since incident management and problem management require different mindsets and skill sets, ensure that training programs are tailored accordingly. Incident teams need quick-thinking and immediate response skills, while problem teams require analytical and investigative skills.

Let’s Overcome Challenges Together

People make up a puzzle.